An opportunity for Holy Land peace
Middle East conference studies the prospect of peace in Israel and Palestine
By Bishop Allen Bartlett
Vol. 75, No. 5, April 2006
The Chinese character for "crisis" is said to be a combination of two characters:
"danger" and "opportunity." Any crisis has both possibilities.
On March 3-4, as the perplexed world, sensing a crisis, watched Hamas come
to power in Palestine and Israel prepare for elections, more than 250 people
from the Washington area and beyond participated in a Middle East conference.
It was entitled "Pursue Justice, Seek Peace: Working together to build a
better future in Palestine and Israel."
My wife Jerrie and I were there, and we found the mood more one of opportunity
We heard a broad array of speakers and workshop leaders, Christian and Jewish,
from Jerusalem and the United States at the conference, held at New York
Avenue Presbyterian Church. The conference was sponsored by Friends of Sabeel
- North America and the Washington Interfaith Alliance for Middle East Peace,
a group with origins in the Diocese of Washington but now independent.
Jean Zaru, presiding clerk of the Ramallah Quakers, told us that representatives
of Hamas had recently visited churches after Sunday services, to say, "We
are brothers and sisters with you seeking justice and relief from oppression."
She pointed out that Hamas cares about those in need, is not corrupt, and
includes women. "Their statements so far do not worry me," she said.
Jeff Halper, an Israeli Jew who directs the Israeli Committee Against Home
Demolitions, said the conflict is emblematic for the Muslim world, the U.S.
and global community, the Jewish community, and as a battleground for human
rights and international law. Because Israel has changed facts on the ground,
he no longer believes a two-state solution is possible. Long-term, Halper
envisioned a future regional confederation of Israel, Palestine, Jordan,
Syria, Lebanon and Egypt.
The Rev. Naim Ateek, director of Sabeel, an ecumenical theology center in
Jerusalem and "Voice of the Palestinian Christians," said Sabeel remains
committed to the two-state solution "for the sake of the Jewish people,"
for whom a Jewish state is crucial. He is an Anglican priest of the Diocese
of Jerusalem, and is an Arab Palestinian citizen of the state of Israel.
In his address Afif Safieh, a Christian who is the new Palestinian diplomatic
representative to the U.S., spoke vigorously on the strong role civil society
can and must play in peacemaking. Like many others, he affirmed that substantial
majorities in both Palestine and Israel want a peaceful, two-state solution.
The challenge is how to do that with Palestinian areas cut up into cantons
by Israeli settlements and their Israeli-only access roads, checkpoints,
the Wall, and Gaza with no seaport, airport, or border crossings.
The issue of divestment from corporations profiting from the occupation was
frequently mentioned as a possible strategy. I was one of six church representatives
presenting the varied stances of our respective denominations. The Episcopal
Church has chosen to follow two tracks: corporate engagement (dialogue with
and challenge to such corporations, and stockholder resolutions) and positive
investment (encouraging investment in Palestinian infrastructure).
Liat Weingart of Jewish Voice for Peace spoke of the "lonely, embattled position"
of progressive Jews (who do not represent mainstream Judaism). She said Christians
seeking dialogue with Jews may encounter "a traumatized response," but she
said Jews want to be engaged. She urged, "Stay in the conversation!" Many
of us also were quite moved by the last plenary address by Sara Roy of Harvard
University, who told her own story as a child of Holocaust survivors.
Among the other speakers and workshop leaders were Don Wagner, Presbyterian
and co-founder of Evangelicals for Middle East Understanding, Professor Susan
Akram of Boston University, an Israel Defense Force Major who had refused
service in Palestine, and Christian Peacemaker Team, International Solidarity
Movement, and the Ecumenical Accompaniment Program participants from Palestine.
The Episcopal Church has for many years supported a just peace that guarantees
Israel's security and Palestinian aspirations for a viable sovereign state
with Jerusalem as the shared capital of both Israel and Palestine. As positions
have hardened, the church in the past 10 years has condemned the violence
of suicide bombers and the occupation, road blocks, settlement construction,
demolition of homes, and the "security wall."
This conference offered a rich fare of examples of persons working toward
justice and peace under terribly difficult circumstances. Hamas has maintained
a tenuous cease-fire for a year, but Palestinians continue to die almost
daily. No one has renounced violence.
Doleful possible scenarios abound. The hope running through the conference
was that the U.S. and other nations will not make premature decisions rooted
in fear of danger, shutting off short and long term actions to help, but
rather allow both sides to find their way forward. Meanwhile, groups and
individuals such as were represented in this conference will fan the guttering
coals of hope that this may be a moment of opportunity.
The Rt. Rev. Allen Bartlett, Retired Bishop of Pennsylvania, served as
Assisting Bishop of Washington 2001-2004.